On September 19, 2009, 8 people who had no way of knowing about each other described a triangle shape, hovering.
no. 1 · wording independence 0.636 by vocabulary, 0.727 by shared phrases · coherence 4.056
Open, all of them
The Phoenix Lights has a name. So does Stephenville, and Tinley Park, and O’Hare. These do not. Same engine, same archive, same checks, and nobody has ever written any of them down as an event.
The engine is not looking for the strange. It is looking for convergence, and then it tries very hard to explain it away. Most convergence has a dull answer and we publish those as readily as these.
| nights where several strangers described the same thing at once | 264 |
| checked against the ordinary record so far | 120 |
| had a plausible ordinary cause, and are labelled as such | 79 |
| had none | 41 |
| of those, events history already has a name for | 17 |
| left with no name and no explanation | 24 |
Every one of these was cross-referenced automatically against the USGS earthquake catalogue, NASA’s fireball and bolide survey, the computed position of Venus and the moon on that date at that place, the geomagnetic Kp index for that day, which is what puts aurora in the sky, and the calendar of nights when people set off fireworks. Aurora was added as a check after this list was published and moved none of these nights off it. If any of those could account for what was described, the night is not on this page. It is on its own page, labelled with the ordinary explanation, where it stays. One honest limit: the fireball catalogue begins in 2015, later than every night on this page, so that particular check has never yet had the chance to remove one.
Not that anything unexplainable happened. It means four specific ordinary causes were ruled out and nobody has looked further, because nobody has ever looked at these at all. There are 144 more candidate nights that have not been through the checking pass yet, and some of those will turn out to have answers too. This is a to-do list, not a conclusion.
Strongest first, by how many people, across how many separate places, and how independently they wrote. The weakest are at the bottom rather than left out, and the ones where the accounts read alike say so on their own line.
On September 19, 2009, 8 people who had no way of knowing about each other described a triangle shape, hovering.
no. 1 · wording independence 0.636 by vocabulary, 0.727 by shared phrases · coherence 4.056
On September 19, 2009, 8 people who had no way of knowing about each other described a hooded figure.
no. 2 · wording independence 0.55 by vocabulary, 0.583 by shared phrases · coherence 3.681
On July 15, 2001, 6 people who had no way of knowing about each other described moving in formation, hovering.
no. 3 · wording independence 0.9 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 4.046
On September 19, 2009, 6 people who had no way of knowing about each other described a beam of light, a bright white light.
no. 4 · wording independence 0.526 by vocabulary, 0.692 by shared phrases · coherence 3.664
On September 19, 2009, 5 people who had no way of knowing about each other described a bright white light.
no. 5 · wording independence 0.667 by vocabulary, 0.75 by shared phrases · coherence 3.261
On August 18, 2012, 4 people who had no way of knowing about each other described red lights, moving in formation.
no. 6 · wording independence 0.892 by vocabulary, 0.929 by shared phrases · coherence 3.395
On October 24, 2012, 6 people who had no way of knowing about each other described moving in formation, hovering, a triangle shape.
no. 7 · wording independence 0.778 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 3.807
On September 11, 1999, 4 people who had no way of knowing about each other described hovering.
no. 8 · wording independence 0.857 by vocabulary, 0.957 by shared phrases · coherence 3.32
On December 12, 2007, 4 people who had no way of knowing about each other described moving in formation.
no. 9 · wording independence 0.853 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 3.31
On February 16, 2000, 8 people who had no way of knowing about each other described a triangle shape, moving in formation.
no. 10 · wording independence 0.793 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 3.727
On May 27, 2009, 6 people who had no way of knowing about each other described hovering, a photograph or recording exists.
no. 11 · wording independence 0.621 by vocabulary, 0.529 by shared phrases · coherence 2.969
On November 8, 2012, 4 people who had no way of knowing about each other described red lights, moving in formation.
no. 12 · wording independence 0.821 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 3.041
On October 23, 2012, 4 people who had no way of knowing about each other described hovering.
no. 13 · wording independence 0.778 by vocabulary, 0.923 by shared phrases · coherence 3.543
On October 23, 2011, 3 people who had no way of knowing about each other described red lights.
no. 14 · wording independence 0.955 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 3.044
On February 21, 2014, 3 people who had no way of knowing about each other described red lights, an orange orb, pulsing light.
no. 15 · wording independence 0.933 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 3.756
On December 11, 2004, 3 people who had no way of knowing about each other described a triangle shape, moving in formation.
no. 16 · wording independence 0.871 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 4.331
On January 7, 2002, 3 people who had no way of knowing about each other described green light, an unexplained boom.
no. 17 · wording independence 0.828 by vocabulary, 0.882 by shared phrases · coherence 3.507
On April 16, 2008, 4 people who had no way of knowing about each other described hovering, an unexplained boom.
no. 18 · wording independence 0.914 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 2.957
On May 14, 2000, 3 people who had no way of knowing about each other described red lights, a triangle shape.
no. 19 · wording independence 0.757 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 3.341
On September 19, 2009, 3 people who had no way of knowing about each other described a beam of light, hovering, vanishing suddenly.
no. 20 · wording independence 0.591 by vocabulary, 0.667 by shared phrases · coherence 2.952
On April 20, 2000, 3 people who had no way of knowing about each other described moving in formation, a triangle shape.
no. 21 · wording independence 0.861 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 3.281
On November 22, 2012, 3 people who had no way of knowing about each other described a triangle shape, an orange orb, hovering.
no. 22 · wording independence 0.811 by vocabulary, 1 by shared phrases · coherence 3.173
On November 15, 2001, 3 people who had no way of knowing about each other described rumbling.
no. 23 · wording independence 0.8 by vocabulary, 0.96 by shared phrases · coherence 3.15
On February 4, 2000, 3 people who had no way of knowing about each other described moving in formation, a triangle shape.
no. 24 · wording independence 0.731 by vocabulary, 0.857 by shared phrases · coherence 3.602
That is the entire reason this page exists. Every one of these is a handful of people and a date. One more account could turn any of them into something, or rule it out, and both are worth having.
Tell us what you sawSomeone who sees lights in the sky writes to one archive. Someone who hears something in the woods writes to another. The two archives do not read each other, and the people certainly don’t. These are the nights the record holds accounts from both, at the same place, on the same date.
3 from the sky archive (NUFORC), 1 from the woods archive (BFRO). They described white light and growling.
possible ordinary cause: venus
2 from the sky archive (NUFORC), 1 from the woods archive (BFRO). They described a triangle shape and knocking.
possible ordinary cause: moon
2 from the sky archive (NUFORC), 1 from the woods archive (BFRO). They described whooping.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
2 from the sky archive (NUFORC), 1 from the woods archive (BFRO). They described knocking and screaming or howling.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
2 from the sky archive (NUFORC), 1 from the woods archive (BFRO). They described an orange orb and screaming or howling.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
Why this list is short, honestly: the detector only clusters accounts that carry a date and a location, and requires both to agree. Most of the record’s newer sources, the French and Italian official files among them, locate cases only to a department or province, so they rarely land in the same cell as a street-level report. As the geography improves, this is where any new crossing will appear.
Nobody filed these as events. They surfaced on their own, when strangers in different places wrote down something similar within hours of each other. 264 of them, drawn out of 53,038 accounts, each checked against earthquakes logged by the USGS, where Venus and the moon actually were, whether it was a day people set off fireworks, and NASA’s fireball survey, though that catalogue only begins in 2015. Of the 264, 79 have at least one ordinary candidate. Strongest first; every one has its own page with the accounts in full.
They described blue light and green light.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described red lights and a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: date
They described red lights and hovering.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described red lights and a triangle shape.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described a triangle shape and moving in formation.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described red lights and a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described an orange orb and red lights.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described blue light and seen again.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described an orange orb and white light.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described an orange orb and moving in formation.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described an orange orb.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described hovering and a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake
They described red lights and hooded.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, moon, date
They described a triangle shape and moving in formation.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described moving in formation and hovering.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described an orange orb and green light.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described an orange orb and green light.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described moving in formation and a triangle shape.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described an orange orb and a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, moon, venus, date
They described a triangle shape and an orange orb.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described a triangle shape and hovering.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described moving in formation and hovering.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described an orange orb and white light.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described moving in formation and a triangle shape.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described red lights and a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described moving in formation and hovering.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described red lights and taking off impossibly fast.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described red lights and an orange orb.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described an orange orb.
possible ordinary cause: moon, date
They described red lights and a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described a triangle shape and moving in formation.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described .
possible ordinary cause: moon, venus
They described moving in formation and a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described hooded.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described a beam of light and white light.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described white light and a beam of light.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described red lights.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described moving in formation and a triangle shape.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described a triangle shape and red lights.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described hovering.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described an orange orb and red lights.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described moving in formation and red lights.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described an orange orb and red lights.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described red lights and moving in formation.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described green light and boom.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described an orange orb.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, moon, venus, date
They described boom and a beam of light.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described white light and growling.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described a triangle shape and knocking.
possible ordinary cause: moon
They described an orange orb.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described an orange orb.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described red lights and moving in formation.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described red lights and hovering.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, moon
They described an orange orb and photographed.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described red lights and moving in formation.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described an orange orb and hovering.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described an orange orb.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake
They described red lights and a triangle shape.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described red lights.
possible ordinary cause: moon, venus
They described hovering.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described a triangle shape and hovering.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described moving in formation.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described an orange orb.
possible ordinary cause: moon, venus
They described red lights.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described moving in formation and an orange orb.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: moon, venus
They described an orange orb and red lights.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described moving in formation and white light.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described moving in formation and a triangle shape.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described an orange orb and multiple witnesses.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described red lights and a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described white light.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described an orange orb and hovering.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described blue light.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, moon, venus
They described a triangle shape and an orange orb.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described hovering.
nothing ordinary found for that afternoon
They described rumbling.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described red lights and white light.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described pilot witness.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described vanishing suddenly.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described red lights.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described red lights and moving in formation.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described hovering and moving in formation.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described an orange orb and red lights.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, date
They described a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described moving in formation.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described an orange orb and moving in formation.
possible ordinary cause: venus, date
They described hovering.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described green light and an orange orb.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described hovering and an orange orb.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described moving in formation and hovering.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described hovering and photographed.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described red lights.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, moon, venus
They described multiple witnesses.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described hovering.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described whooping.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake, venus
They described hovering and boom.
nothing ordinary found for that night
They described moving in formation and a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described a triangle shape and red lights.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described a beam of light and hovering.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described a triangle shape.
possible ordinary cause: earthquake
They described hovering and an orange orb.
possible ordinary cause: date
They described an orange orb.
nothing ordinary found for that evening
They described a triangle shape and hovering.
possible ordinary cause: venus
They described an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a triangle shape.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a beam of light and hovering.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a triangle shape.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described knocking and screaming or howling.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described white light and pilot witness.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described hovering.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described vanishing suddenly and moving in formation.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described green light.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a triangle shape and pilot witness.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described hovering.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described vanishing suddenly.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described hovering.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a triangle shape.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described pilot witness.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb and moving in formation.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described pilot witness.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a triangle shape.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described moving in formation and an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb and moving in formation.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described moving in formation and a triangle shape.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described vanishing suddenly.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb and screaming or howling.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described moving in formation.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described hovering and moving in formation.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a triangle shape.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described vanishing suddenly.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described moving in formation.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described vanishing suddenly.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a triangle shape.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described moving in formation and an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described moving in formation and vanishing suddenly.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described buzzing and hovering.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described hovering.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described moving in formation and pulsing light.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described red lights.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described photographed.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described hovering.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described pulsing light.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described moving in formation.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described hovering.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a triangle shape.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described pulsing light and red lights.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a triangle shape and a beam of light.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described moving in formation.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described a triangle shape.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described green light.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described moving in formation.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described white light.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described an orange orb and red lights.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described hovering.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described red lights.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described red lights and blue light.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described hovering.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described red lights.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described green light.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described pulsing light and moving in formation.
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
They described .
not yet through the ordinary-record checking pass
Built from 53,038 accounts by the method described at /method, which includes the ten famous events used to test whether any of this works and the one it failed to find